GSY REVIEW | X360, PS3 Tuesday, May 25, 2010 | 3:15 PM

Gamersyde Review:
Red Dead Redemption

Gamersyde Review: <br>Red Dead Redemption

After months spent waiting, watching images and videos, and from time to time taking part to previews which just made the waiting even more unbearable, Red Dead Redemption is at last available on Playstation 3 and Xbox 360. Considering the huge amount of news and articles written about the game, we felt sort of compelled to end the story with a genuine made-in-Gamersyde review. Here’s the verdict, just after the click.





Let’s not spend too much time describing the background of Red Dead Redemption, having already discussed it in our two previous articles last December and last January. For sure, Rockstar’s bet to choose 1911 as the beginning of an epic adventure in a declining Far West is already won, the context being simultaneously original, realistic, and incredibly violent. Primal racism, cruelty towards women and the weakest, you will have to face all of it during John Marston’s quest for redemption. After a great introduction sequence, where the piano tunes reminds us of Lost in its most melancholic moments, where we can see a car being dropped off the ship – most likely a reference to the opening sequence of GTA4 – and where characters and landscapes are introduced to us with Rockstar’s usual excellence, we can finally begin the adventure. And what an adventure!



The strength of Red Dead Redemption undoubtly comes from the excellent work done on the atmosphere. The world Marston lives in really seems alive, and this contributes to giving credit to the game. From the arrival in Armadillo, which we unveiled last week in our first 10 minute video, to the surrounding nature and the McFarlane ranch where Marston will make his first friends, it’s very hard not to literally dive into early 20th-century America. Dust blown away in the streets, farm animals, citizens busy whith their day-to-day activities, snapping flags and the sound of the leaves blowing in the wind, everything is put in place to immerse the player, even when nothing special happens on the screen. Red Dead Redemption’s universe is not still, and it lets you enjoy all the vitality coming from it.



If most of Marston’s activities will involve tough gunfights between badass desperados, he won’t necessarily have to shoot. Aiming at a complete and varied game, Rockstar filled it with all the activities we can expect from a Western : breaking horses, herding cattle, hunting, picking plants, money games (among which poker, black-jack, dice games or even the horseshoe game, etc.), setting up a scam with the local crook to sell Dr Doxey’s elixir, and even more. More surprisingly, especially when you forget the story is actually set in 1911, it’s even possible to go the town theater and watch some of the several short silent movies. Treasure hunting is also available, with maps showing little sketches of the place marked with a cross. The great thing is that the player can only rely on his observation skills to find the precious loot.



The game doesn’t forget pure action though, a good opportunity to relax after cheating at a poker game, and to check if the controls of the character have evolved in a good way since GTA4. Three control modes are available, casual, normal, expert. For the first one, you have a system similar in every way to Niko’s in 2007: automatic aim, change of target with the right stick. Normal mode is a little more assisted than expert mode but barely. If you want the fully manual mode, then go with expert mode. First problem encountered when playing in this mode, aiming is awfully slow, even when pushing the sticks' sensitivity to the maximum. Considering this, Red Dead Redemption is ages behind best-in-class Uncharted and Gears of War. It’s not easy to forgive the lack of reactivity in a game where it’s one of the major components of the gameplay, but still, you get used to it, the slow motion launched with the Dead Eye mode enabling to compensate the problem.

The movements of the character aren’t very smooth either as soon as you are obliged to move around in small places such as the inside of a house, thankfully, it does not happen that much. This being said, the quality of the animations is so good, humans and animals alike, that you finally forget such flaws. Especially considering that the cover system seems to be more efficient than before. When you’re riding a horse, once you’ve got used to the controls (A to use your spurs – don’t overuse it to avoid exhausting your horse – RB to take the reins and ask him to slow down), it is really enjoyable to play. It’s not always easy to aim while gallopping full speed, but the least gifted of us will still be able to use casual aim mode. I was talking earlier of the impressive work accomplished on the animations, but hit detection is also way better than in GTA4. Shooting every possible part of a target's body and watching the effects it causes never gets old.

As the Wild West without duels wouldn’t make more sense than a cheeseburger without cheese, we obviously have face-to-face duels in the pure tradition of western movies. As your fame increases, you are regularly duelled by some trigger happy dudes wishing to steal your thunder to get a better place in the sun. Up to you to accept the challenge or not, but after all, it’s always tempting to break a young fool’s dream, isn't it? Rather simple compared with those from Call of Juarez Bound in Blood, you just have to hit the left trigger to unshethe your gun, then aim at as many lethal parts as possible on your opponent’s body (a bar is available to assess each competitor’s damages) and you’re the winner. Or not… Awesomeness being to disarm your opponent and let him live with his shame for only friend.



As great as it is, Red Dead Redemption could have pushed it further in some areas of the game. The only point of hunting and plants picking for example is money, while we could have hoped to be able to use the precious meat to gain health between two shootings. Along the same lines, we definitely regret that campgrounds don’t have the same functions as in Japanese RPGs (save the game, which is possible here, but also healing). To make all of these things possible, they just had to implement a health system different from what you find in Gears of War/Uncharted/CoD, and, like in other sandbox games like GTA4 or Just Cause 2, give the character a real health bar that needs refill from time to time. This is nitpicking really, but it’s kind of important if you think what the gameplay could have been if it had stayed true to the idea of "survival of the fittest in a harsh environment". After all, what kind of threat is a rattlesnake when you don’t have to fear the effect of poison?

Too bad also that the game suffers from occasional glitches (more or less funny), a few massive slowdowns (luckily rare) without any apparent reason (yes, on Xbox 360 too, for those who would tend to doubt this) and a few pop-up issues on some elements of the environment. Apart from that, it’s a flawless victory, with an enormous map (even it may seem small at first), lighting effects that are both beautiful and realistic, giving each moment of the day a specific atmosphere. The day and night cycle lets us witness a more active fauna as soon as night comes, and you will quickly realize how leaving the trail can become dangerous when cougars are nearby (we’re talking about animals here). Beautiful too, the thunder storms and the lightning almost make us want to shut down all electric appliances of the house in case they all fry. At every corner, you are rewarded with a new vista, and for nature lovers like me, the game’s offering everything we expected.



Talking about strolls, I’d like to end this review talking about the Free Roam mode which lets you share some good manly time with your friend list. Here again, everything’s not perfect, and you can only regret that the world seems emptier than in one player mode, even if you get a more fluid and stable framerate. A few forts defended by the AI, a few other more classical modes (deathmatch and CTF for example) but mostly long rides on your horses to fulfill everyone's desire, even the strangest ones. The huge video (in every way) below will let you appreciate, I hope, the good mood ruling during these sessions, and will give you the chance to discover some new breathtaking landscapes. We want to mention that no animal has been hurt during the shooting of this video and Gamersyde is in no way responsible for the violent and irresponsible behavior of some of its members.



Verdict


Red Dead Redemption may not be perfect but it’s at least the great game we’ve been waiting for months, and we did not expect any less from it. Once the few flaws have been forgotten, there is nothing else to do but to congratulate Rockstar for this meticulous retranscription of a part of American history. Full of life, thanks to a varied flora and fauna, as well as all these random events on the road, it’s impossible not to rush to such a golden experience, what will clearly become the new sandbow game reference. A title Gamersyde can only recommend if dust and horses don’t frighten you.

Introduction
Stroll
Varied gameplay
Action gameplay
Environments
Multiplayer

All comments

Commented on 2010-05-25 15:24:41
Reference??

That title was given only to Bayonetta before,that means this game is a freaking masterpiece in motion!!!

God Dammnit!!!!!

I want my game now!!!
Commented on 2010-05-25 15:24:58
Awesome game! Good job on the review guys!
Commented on 2010-05-25 15:36:08
Is this 360 footage on the Environments section? Then the LOD Pop-in is still kinda awfull.
Commented on 2010-05-25 15:41:33
The game is great. I really love it. But the combat inherited from GTA IV still sucks, which probably is why the game is so easy, unless you remove autotargeting.
Commented on 2010-05-25 15:43:46
Please ONE GIANT favour Gamersyde. Keep your reviews as they are .... DO NOT, for all time's sake, introduce a scoring system now or in the near or far future, please :)

Great review, thanks.
Commented on 2010-05-25 15:48:34 In reply to alimokrane
Posted by alimokrane
Please ONE GIANT favour Gamersyde. Keep your reviews as they are .... DO NOT, for all time's sake, introduce a scoring system now or in the near or far future, please :)

Great review, thanks.
How much you offer?
Commented on 2010-05-25 16:00:53 In reply to IRAIPT0IR
Posted by IRAIPT0IR
How much you offer?
I'll offer my fidelity to the website ;)
Commented on 2010-05-25 17:13:38 In reply to spif2001
Posted by spif2001
The game is great. I really love it. But the combat inherited from GTA IV still sucks, which probably is why the game is so easy, unless you remove autotargeting.
Hmm,i think the combat and cover systems are huge improvement. I hate them in IV, and love it on Red Dead. Go figure.
Expert aim all the way. All of the complains for being too easy came from people playing on casual/normal lol.
My GOTY so far and this is the best game from Rockstar IMO.
Commented on 2010-05-25 17:31:11 In reply to Seth
Posted by Seth
Hmm,i think the combat and cover systems are huge improvement. I hate them in IV, and love it on Red Dead. Go figure.
This part right here its what is keeping my hopes up that I will love it too,I am at the same situation like you I hated them in GTA4 and I really hope I loved them here!
Commented on 2010-05-25 17:35:47
Can you shag the prostitutes?
Commented on 2010-05-25 18:16:31 In reply to IRAIPT0IR
Posted by IRAIPT0IR
Reference??

That title was given only to Bayonetta before,that means this game is a freaking masterpiece in motion!!!

God Dammnit!!!!!

I want my game now!!!
IRAIPT0IR

I had to think of you when I saw those cute Japanese Girl in some very nice looking Bayonetta cosplay

check it out

http://kotaku.com/5520098/japans-biggest-cosplay-e...

Gonna love those !

Anyway..RDR is a very nice game,that capures you in fron of the screen...right now can't stop playing,so..talk to u guys later.
Commented on 2010-05-25 18:16:51 In reply to IRAIPT0IR
Posted by IRAIPT0IR
This part right here its what is keeping my hopes up that I will love it too,I am at the same situation like you I hated them in GTA4 and I really hope I loved them here!
Nothing to worry about. I disliked the shooting in GTAIV, but here it's bloody well done. It feels natural.
Commented on 2010-05-25 18:18:34 In reply to iosomewhere
Posted by iosomewhere
IRAIPT0IR

I had to think of you when I saw those cute Japanese Girl in some very nice looking Bayonetta cosplay

check it out

http://kotaku.com/5520098/japans-biggest-cosplay-e...

Gonna love those !

Anyway..RDR is a very nice game,that capures you in fron of the screen...right now can't stop playing,so..talk to u guys later.
Oh my.......those pics....thanks for the link bro!!!
Commented on 2010-05-25 20:06:56 In reply to IRAIPT0IR
Posted by IRAIPT0IR
Oh my.......those pics....thanks for the link bro!!!
She's wearing an outfit. That's not right now, is it?
Commented on 2010-05-26 11:11:28
Can you tie the criminal and take him back to jail? If true, that would be perfect!
Commented on 2010-05-26 14:57:43 In reply to digi_matrix
Posted by digi_matrix
Can you tie the criminal and take him back to jail? If true, that would be perfect!
If you accept the Bounty then yes. You can take him dead or alive.
Commented on 2010-05-26 15:04:55 In reply to digi_matrix
Posted by digi_matrix
Can you tie the criminal and take him back to jail? If true, that would be perfect!
You can even catch him with the lasso, tie him up pigstyle, load him up your horse and drive him around for fun :)
Commented on 2010-05-26 15:15:04 In reply to IRAIPT0IR
@ RAIPT0IR

Anytime man ;)
Commented on 2010-05-26 21:31:38
Great review :), Im still to play this game.. But after watching those videos i really want to get it.

It sorta just looks like the western version of GTA.
Commented on 2010-05-26 22:23:16 In reply to mattdamon
Posted by mattdamon
Is this 360 footage on the Environments section? Then the LOD Pop-in is still kinda awfull.
Is there anything else you do other than whining and comlaining?
Commented on 2010-05-28 13:39:52
Red Dead Redemption deserves all the praise it gets. Its a breath of fresh air in todays half assed game designs.
Commented on 2010-06-03 15:20:05
Awesome game

About the game


What's up?
  • Wheat_Thins
    Wheat_Thins No EDRAM or anything architectully odd to work against when getting the engine to run on Windows / Linux. (20 minutes ago)
  • Wheat_Thins
    Wheat_Thins @Melmoth: PS4 is literally a (in 2016) a very low end gaming PC. Why do you think death stranding will be difficult to port to PC? (22 minutes ago)
  • Sdarts
    Sdarts Frank Tieri's works, mostly X-Men related: [url] So that's very encouraging. (1 Hour ago)
  • Sdarts
    Sdarts * Ultimate Marvel vs. Capcom 3 (1 Hour ago)
  • Sdarts
    Sdarts There will also be a PC version, just like Ultimate Marvel vs. Capcom. Also, Single-Player modes - including Story (with Frank Tieri), 2v2, many multiplayer features, is on Unreal Engine 4. (1 Hour ago)
  • Sdarts
    Sdarts @GriftGFX: Not sure if you saw this: Marvel vs. Capcom: Infinite's info with many important details: [url] Seems there will be X-Men and F4 characters. (1 Hour ago)
  • Sdarts
    Sdarts NeoGAF - The Last Guardian: Review Thread: [url] Great to see that all of the wait wasn't in vain. (1 Hour ago)
PreviousNext
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood GSY is getting some nice content at 3 pm CEST with our July podcast and some videos of the Deus Ex Mankind Divided preview build. :) (> 3 Months ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood For once we'll be live at 4:30 pm CEST. Blim should not even be tired! (> 3 Months ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood More Quantum Break coverage coming in a few hours, 9:00 a.m CEST. (> 3 Months ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood We'll have a full review up for Firewatch at 7 pm CET. Videos will only be tomorrow though. (> 3 Months ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood Tonight's livestream will be at 9:15 GMT+1, not GMT+2 as first stated. (> 3 Months ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood New GSY Live dedicated this time to Just Cause 3 on Tuesday 9:30 GMT+2 (> 3 Months ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood Join us tomorrow at 10 pm GMT+2 for a new livestream. We'll be playing Rise of the Tomb Raider. (> 3 Months ago)
PreviousNext
Top stories