GAMERSYDE | X360, PS3 Thursday, January 28, 2010 | 11:00 PM

Red Dead Redemption Hands-On

Red Dead Redemption Hands-On

After a second presentation of Red Dead Redemption last week, we figured you might be interested in reading our hands-on article. Last week's presentation gave us the opportunity to get our hands on a slightly more recent build of the game. More details inside.
Update 2: English trailer added.

I won't go into as much depth as the previous article, I want to talk about the story in which you player are going to evolve. Rockstar's new hero, John Marston, is left for dead by his comrades after a robbery that has gone bad. Thinking that he owed his survival to a sign of fate, John settles down and decides to raise a family, far away from the violence of the west he used to know. Unfortunately, the American government forces John back into business and asks him to pursue his former partners. As it is after this is America, Marston doesn't have much of a choice but to comply since his family is being held hostage as a guarantee of his cooperation.

During this presentation, we were shown three missions from the main story and one that looked more of a side quest. Unsurprisingly, each of them involved a lot of gun fire, but tried some variations to hold the fun with different weapons, places and situations.



First, we find Marston in the desert, mountainside while he must clear a path to the right-hand of an army Colonel, a cowardly Mexican officer who wants to avoid the battlefield at all costs. To do so, he becomes the official supplier of the General, ready to fulfil each of his whims. Accompanied with allied soldiers, the player must progress carefully, switching from a sniper rifle to kill shooters in the canyon's heights, to revolver or shotgun to clear a path through the mass of opponents rushing down the dusty track leading up to the main objective. We then had a lot of fun shooting at army soldiers, so soon as we opened fire on the soldiers we immediately saw the Wanted system come into affect. Indeed, at the first gunshots, we got ourselves our very first Wanted sign, appearing in the top right corner of the screen and never fading out, well, not until we've loaded the next mission that is.

At the beginning of the second mission, we met the Sheriff of a small town situated in the middle of a rocky desert full of cacti. Being after a man on the run, Marston is looking for some help and so he decides to ask the Sheriff, who doesn't seem to be receptive to his demand. According to him, he already has a lot on his hands and can't take care of everything, especially when the problems are beyond his jurisdiction. Marston decides to cut a deal with the sheriff by help the Sheriff provided the sheriff returns the favour. After heading to the saloon to locate a henchman on the Sheriff's wanted list, the player has to tail him by horse until we reach a small cabin outside of town. After a manly discussion involving gun powder (and a tutorial of the cover system) the mission is over and we move on.



Looking more like a side quest mission, the next sequence showed us a farmer asking Marston for help as his daughter needs saving. She is held hostage in her own farm by some bad guys who are keeping her father away from the house. Brave being Marston's middle name, he sneaks to the farmhouse's surroundings and takes cover. Once all the outside enemies are dead, theres still one enemy inside. This situation requires to be quick and effective, the Dead Eye function which slows down time comes in handy in such situations - you don't want the victim to be killed, or even worse, you don't want to destroy or damage the furniture.

Finally, in the last mission, Marston is seeking a Gatling gun. After a brief meeting with an Irishman, an old drunk Marston already saved previously in the game, Marston must take on a mine occupied by some disreputable men. Unlike previous missions, this one offers a more linear section, which does not come as a surprise since it's a mine gallery, with a subdued lighting atmosphere. The mission ends with Marston hanging on to a small rail truck carrying the Gatling gun, a scene you may have seen in the latest trailer of the game.



The Good, the Bad and the Beautiful

Graphically, the game has already evolved, with an impressive draw distance, polished textures and a rather unobtrusive pop-up. The large wild areas will certainly give hours and hours to roam free. The work they have achieved with the animations is absolutely outstanding, the muscles on the horses react according to their movements, which are very realistic as far as I can tell. Enemies do not fall down all in the same way, and their reaction will change depending on where they have been hit, which again makes the game even more true to life. Depending on the time, there are subtle lighting changes bringing some more realism and there is little doubt that the postcard look of these magnificent views will be remembered for a while.

A word on the cutscenes which, as usual with Rockstar, are wonderfully rendered. All the different faces are always very expressive with some great lip-synchronization sustained with a good voice acting to top it off. The cast of characters already looks as colorful as we would expect and it will hopefully be rich enough as not to disappoint in the end.

This more recent build of the game still suffers from small bugs, of course, and a strangely low framerate when in town areas (while in the countryside, even attacked by a dozen enemies, the game runs smoothly) but it's still a work in progress and therefore not representative of what the final build will be. AI (allies and enemies alike) seems to be quite good, taking cover and doing everything to bring down their target. A good thing then, because our companions didn't seem to want to relax and let us do all the dirty work. On the other hand, we were unable to judge the difficulty of the game given that the demo was in God mode. They obviously did not want to risk having us die at every corner but it was however a blatant lack of trust in my innate skills. But well, never mind.



In Guns we trust

Our major fear regarding the playability of the game was essentially about the aiming system and the character's movements. First, know that regular GTA IV players won't be disoriented by the pad configuration, aside from Dead Eye function assigned to the R3 button. As a result, it is very easy to pick up and we soon felt completely at ease. While the player is on foot the game doesn't feel that much difference from GTA IV, Marston still seems more responsive and thus easier to handle than Niko. The aiming system (automatic or manual) is therefore more nervous yet less difficult to apprehend. Add to that the fact that moving around feels less awkward and you find yourself playing a much more pleasant game. There's still those odd cover glitches when Marston chooses to stick to wrong part of the scenery, but nothing too serious that you won't find in all the best games in the genre.

Let's now talk about the Dead Eye function that I mentioned earlier. When the player pushes the right analog stick, the game switches to slow motion, allowing you to move a reticle and have more time to aim where you want before letting your guns do all the talking and making a real mess. It works rather well, although the system in itself is not really original. We couldn't get any information on how to refill the meter affiliated to this function but I bet that our next meeting will lift the veil on this point.



Walking on foot feels good, but there is nothing like galloping on the back of a horse. The Good news is, this part of the game has been nailed by Rockstar. Horse riding is indeed really pleasant from trotting to a full gallop. They also had a very simple idea that should satisfy the non English speakers. You know, all the players who always whine at the driving sequences of GTA IV where they have to keep an eye on the traffic and the subtitles at the same time. Sure, it is not easy to understand a whole discussion when driving from point A to point B when you're not even able to follow and understand a full Teletubbies episode in English. In Red Dead Redemption you can now lock on to the horse you are following (e.g: the Sheriff of the second mission) by holding the A button. Your horse then switchers to autopilot mode, giving you plenty of time to admire the view or read the subtitles of the conversation. An utterly simple idea, easy to implement in this situation, (traffic jams are pretty rare in the desert) but it adds more comfort to the gameplay.

Finally, Rockstar showed us the challenge system they've incorporated into the game. After a shoot-out, fresh dead bodies will obviously attract hungry vultures - another example of Rockstar's attention to details. One of the challenges was to shoot down five of these vultures to get the the first rank of the marksman. We bet that Rockstar has prepared us a large amount of challenge, with hopefully some fun surprises that could help us develop our character.



Overall impressions
Red Dead Redemption continues to seduce us and this extra hour we spent with John Marston will not lower our enthusiasm, quite the contrary. We don't see how Rockstar could fail to deliver with this ambitious game and such an incredible atmosphere. While waiting to learn and see more of this game, we remain very optimistic and we definitely look forward to our next meeting with the game.

Trailer
English Trailer

All comments

Page 1 2 3 >>
Commented on 2010-01-28 19:27:03
Very nice impressions,thanks for that.

I cant wait for the game I hope after Crackdown and the letdown that was GTA4 this would be my next open world game to sink a lot of time!!
Commented on 2010-01-28 19:34:53 In reply to IRAIPT0IR
Posted by IRAIPT0IR
Very nice impressions,thanks for that.

I cant wait for the game I hope after Crackdown and the letdown that was GTA4 this would be my next open world game to sink a lot of time!!
Agreed, GTA4 was such a letdown and step back in the serie but this little beauty looks good...so far. Thanks for impressions guys, great work.
Commented on 2010-01-28 19:43:45
GTA4 a letdown? crazy
Commented on 2010-01-28 20:05:09
Thanks for the preview.
Commented on 2010-01-28 20:11:10
GTA IV was amazing, and this one will be even better. Can't wait.
Commented on 2010-01-28 20:21:19
@Driftwood Can you elaborate on the horse auto-pilot? Do you hold down, then let go, and horse goes into auto-pilot? Or is it like GTA 4 where you hold down a button and it's just the camera that stays locked on?

If the horse drives independently of your input, that's a great thing, because shooting from a bike on GTA 4 while chasing bikers was one of the most frustrating trial-and-error experiences ever.
Commented on 2010-01-28 20:31:54
GTA4 a let down? Maybe if you were expecting some of mildly entertaining side activities that San Andreas had. Which was unrealistic to expect, considering they built the whole game from scratch using some very impressive tech, and it still required a six month delay.

But to call GTA4 a step back is ridiculous. I can't even imagine being entertained my GTA3, Vice City or San Andreas after playing GTA4.
Commented on 2010-01-28 20:32:15 In reply to digi_matrix
Posted by digi_matrix
@Driftwood Can you elaborate on the horse auto-pilot? Do you hold down, then let go, and horse goes into auto-pilot? Or is it like GTA 4 where you hold down a button and it's just the camera that stays locked on?
No, the horse keeps going in the right direction when you're locked. It's not just like in GTA. :)
Commented on 2010-01-28 20:50:26
that new trailer looks great. Getting really pumped for this game.. i hope Rockstar refuse to feed their employee's untill the framerates rock solid though.
Commented on 2010-01-28 21:05:39
GTA 4 was a let down, sorry fellas, it just was. It was a disapointment to most because of the hype Rockstar built up for it. Their engine was extremely impressive, but you got the sense that they weren't exploiting it enough or taking full advantage of the Euphoria engine. How hard could it have been to allow Niko to grab onto the boot of a car as it raced along, or the side of a train, or run and jump onto a police chopper and frantically try to hang onto it as it flew around trying to shake you off? It's a little thing like that that could have made GTA 4 far more entertaining and FUN than what it was. In it's own right, a great game, but it was lacking in certain areas that the likes of Vice City and San Andreas had. Looking at Red Dead, however, makes me wonder if it could be the game that GTA 4 promised to be but failed on. Just the simple fact that you can mask your face to commit a crime is both realistic and common sense, so why wasn't it in GTA 4? Again, it's the small details that matter.
Commented on 2010-01-28 21:18:06
By the way guys, we're sorry we've only put the French version of the trailer so far. We'll add the English one ASAP.
Commented on 2010-01-28 21:21:35
Those graphics are stunning. Just amazing how much detail there is for a sandbox game.

Day one for me.
Commented on 2010-01-28 21:38:43
I'm having high hopes for this one! Looks splendid!
Commented on 2010-01-28 22:34:56
Looks terrific, not so great framerate, and that rarely gets fixed. Here's hoping cause it looks too brilliant
Commented on 2010-01-28 22:59:14 In reply to Driftwood
Posted by Driftwood
By the way guys, we're sorry we've only put the French version of the trailer so far. We'll add the English one ASAP.
It's all good Driftwood. I think I got the gist of it...
Commented on 2010-01-28 23:05:36
English trailer is up. Sorry again for the delay but I found out the first trailer was in French a bit too late. :)
Commented on 2010-01-28 23:12:29
Driftwood,

I'm starting to think that this might be the game to rival Mass Effect 2 for GOTY. I wonder if you felt it "had it".

A bit too early to tell but this one distillates quality.
Commented on 2010-01-28 23:16:46 In reply to OldSchoolGamer
The game clearly looks promising, to say the least. Now I must say I don't really like this GOTY idea when talking about games so you won't see me claim so. :)

If the full lives up to its expectations, it's going to be pretty huge, that's all I can say for sure.
Commented on 2010-01-28 23:33:33
How it felt controlling the character and the aiming and shooting Drift?

Can you say it feels good controlling the character?

Thats all that matters to the controlling character gameplay and some variety in missions.
Commented on 2010-01-28 23:38:17 In reply to IRAIPT0IR
Well I think I made it rather clear in the article, didn't I?
Commented on 2010-01-28 23:47:19
No I didnt see that part.........


*runs and hides*
Commented on 2010-01-28 23:47:59
Had Microsoft not have gotten Rockstar on board this generation, they would have been in some serious trouble. These games sell consoles. Kudos to Microsoft. Unbelievable is an understatement.
Commented on 2010-01-29 00:02:39 In reply to dingleberry
Posted by dingleberry
GTA 4 was a let down, sorry fellas, it just was. It was a disapointment to most because of the hype Rockstar built up for it. Their engine was extremely impressive, but you got the sense that they weren't exploiting it enough or taking full advantage of the Euphoria engine. How hard could it have been to allow Niko to grab onto the boot of a car as it raced along, or the side of a train, or run and jump onto a police chopper and frantically try to hang onto it as it flew around trying to shake you off? It's a little thing like that that could have made GTA 4 far more entertaining and FUN than what it was. In it's own right, a great game, but it was lacking in certain areas that the likes of Vice City and San Andreas had. Looking at Red Dead, however, makes me wonder if it could be the game that GTA 4 promised to be but failed on. Just the simple fact that you can mask your face to commit a crime is both realistic and common sense, so why wasn't it in GTA 4? Again, it's the small details that matter.
i found the hype for GTA4 perfectly justified and it was by far the best game in the series, but then i prefer more mature, grounded experiences as opposed to over the top experiences (reason why i truely detest saints row 2)

this however, well, i'm not a fan of westerns in the slightest, and the even bigger open world worries the hell out of me. (spreading the gameplay they have a bit too thin imo, just like just casue did) but it's definately worth a rental, most R* games are. the first game in this series wasnt that great tho. it was a pretty lacklustre shooter. but if you love western then it's going to up your interest 10 fold. sadly, i dont.
Commented on 2010-01-29 04:31:24 In reply to dingleberry
Posted by dingleberry
GTA 4 was a let down, sorry fellas, it just was. It was a disapointment to most because of the hype Rockstar built up for it.
I can respect your points, but what hype?

They released, what... 4 trailers, and barely said anything about the game.
Commented on 2010-01-29 07:38:09
A little off-topic, GTA 4 was an overall letdown on a game design perspective. Outdated and frustrating in so many ways. A miserable experience, gameplay- and story-wise.

Which is why I'm mildly excited with this game. It's not the same design team as GTA4(thank god), which means possibly better exploration and sidequests, and it looks like the open-world version of the 1st game. So yeah, my hate for GTA 4 doesn't stop me from getting on the bandwagon for this game since they're not the same developers. Yay!
Page 1 2 3 >>

About the game


What's up?
  • Moonwalker
    Moonwalker Another Switch/PC game, coming 2018, lol. [url] (1 minute ago)
  • Tiz
    Tiz @alimokrane: Only 9 more re-ups for the achievement! I was trying to level up my Horde classes and then FFXV hit. Now with the Halo update dropping about 3 hours ago, Gears will have to wait. (27 minutes ago)
  • alimokrane
    alimokrane hands down my most played MP game ever this.... (29 minutes ago)
  • alimokrane
    alimokrane I am so addicted to Gears 4 MP. Just hit max level 100 and re-upped again lol (30 minutes ago)
  • Megido
    Megido @amerakindesi: Never played a moba before? Didn't find it particularly complex personally. but a bit bland and boring. (1 Hour ago)
  • amerakindesi
    amerakindesi damn if that game isn't confusing though. lots of stuff going on. i feel like i need to read a manual before i can play it (1 Hour ago)
  • amerakindesi
    amerakindesi gigantic preview (open demo) now available on x1 and windows free (1 Hour ago)
PreviousNext
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood GSY is getting some nice content at 3 pm CEST with our July podcast and some videos of the Deus Ex Mankind Divided preview build. :) (> 3 Months ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood For once we'll be live at 4:30 pm CEST. Blim should not even be tired! (> 3 Months ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood More Quantum Break coverage coming in a few hours, 9:00 a.m CEST. (> 3 Months ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood We'll have a full review up for Firewatch at 7 pm CET. Videos will only be tomorrow though. (> 3 Months ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood Tonight's livestream will be at 9:15 GMT+1, not GMT+2 as first stated. (> 3 Months ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood New GSY Live dedicated this time to Just Cause 3 on Tuesday 9:30 GMT+2 (> 3 Months ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood Join us tomorrow at 10 pm GMT+2 for a new livestream. We'll be playing Rise of the Tomb Raider. (> 3 Months ago)
PreviousNext
Top stories