The Witcher 3: PS4 vs XB1 video

Eamon

Commented on 2015-05-16 20:09:57

A comparison between PC release and VGX/Sword of Destiny trailers would be nice.

In reply to

OptionalLemon

Commented on 2015-05-16 20:13:21

Thanks for all the high-quality videos Gamersyde, this has become THE place to go to for me for videogaming content

In reply to

Moonwalker

Commented on 2015-05-16 21:23:30

Is this with the patch applied?

In reply to

Nanosecond

Commented on 2015-05-16 21:38:35

PS4 version looks a bit crisper, probably due to the higher resolution.

In reply to

Moonwalker

Commented on 2015-05-16 21:46:32

The real difference i see is that in one part it looks a lot brighter on PS4 and more..toned down or darker i guess, on Xbox One. But from what i read on GAF, the X1 has clearly a worse framerate, but neither version is a locked 30fps. Good lord, not even a locked 30fps. I'll just accept it and enjoy it. I know i will enjoy it. Plus....i decided to buy Risen on 360 a few years ago and that framerate was truly laughable. This should be ok.

In reply to

makenshi1985

Commented on 2015-05-16 21:47:39

if this video was to show that the two are barely indistinguishable then fine, but this way of doing comparison isnt really the best :(

In reply to

Moonwalker

Commented on 2015-05-16 21:55:45

Another good way to compare them yourselves is download the Xbox One and PS4 video(s) and directly compare them yourself side by side.

Blimblim

Was the Xbox One's Color space at standard or PC RGB? standard can make some games look a bit.....bland i guess, and PC RGB makes them much more vibrant and colourful, but it also crushes black levels. Unless the tv supports it.

In reply to

kraenk

Commented on 2015-05-16 22:24:50

The PS4 version looks more vibrant and clear. It's pretty spectacular what they have done with this limited hardware on both systems though.

In reply to

Moonwalker

Commented on 2015-05-16 22:35:38 In reply to kraenk

Posted by kraenk

The PS4 version looks more vibrant and clear. It's pretty spectacular what they have done with this limited hardware on both systems though.

Really? Cause i don't see it. I made a comparison of my own by downloading the last video on the Xbox One videos article and downloading the last video in the PS4 videos article. I put the videos next to eachother...and to be honest, i do not see the difference.

In reply to

kraenk

Commented on 2015-05-16 22:42:21 In reply to Moonwalker

Posted by Moonwalker

Really? Cause i don't see it. I made a comparison of my own by downloading the last video on the Xbox One videos article and downloading the last video in the PS4 videos article. I put the videos next to eachother...and to be honest, i do not see the difference.

One definitely can see it on smaller details like Geralt's chain armor or far away object like trees. It's still great it seems everyone will have an amazing looking game to play, despite all the downgrade haters.

In reply to

Moonwalker

Commented on 2015-05-16 22:46:34 In reply to kraenk

Oh but i agree with that it has clearly seen downgrades. Compare the reveal trailer to this and damn......

I think people are right when they assume if these consoles had not existed, it would have looked like that on PC. But the reality is, they do exist. It still looks awesome.

In reply to

radsy

Commented on 2015-05-16 22:55:32

i appreciate gamersyde doing comparison videos so much . gamersyde have the best quality videos.
just one thing , a side by side comparison is the way to go .
cant compare too much this way .
better if 1 half is ps4 full screen and other half xbox one full screen

In reply to

Nanosecond

Commented on 2015-05-16 23:26:08 In reply to Moonwalker

Posted by Moonwalker

The real difference i see is that in one part it looks a lot brighter on PS4 and more..toned down or darker i guess, on Xbox One. But from what i read on GAF, the X1 has clearly a worse framerate, but neither version is a locked 30fps. Good lord, not even a locked 30fps. I'll just accept it and enjoy it. I know i will enjoy it. Plus....i decided to buy Risen on 360 a few years ago and that framerate was truly laughable. This should be ok.

Hmm, a bit surprised to hear about worse frame rate on XB since everyone was assuming the opposite (that the PS4's 1080p would result in lower frame rate), lol.

In reply to

Moonwalker

Commented on 2015-05-16 23:29:21

Yeah but on Reddit the exact opposite is being sad. Frankly i don't care. I'm just gonna look forward to next week now.

In reply to

ramiuk1

Commented on 2015-05-16 23:50:17 In reply to Moonwalker

I been playing it on ps4 for a few hours today and it does have frame issues and other issues that are annoying,like stuck on trees and trying to select things(looting).
oh and hte game seems too big in a way,apart fro mthat its an amazing game so far.

In reply to

This message and account have been deleted at the user's request

timotim

Commented on 2015-05-17 02:15:16

We need more vids from you guys...I dont trust the other guys (DF)

In reply to

scoobs0688

Commented on 2015-05-17 04:33:02 In reply to timotim

Posted by timotim

We need more vids from you guys...I dont trust the other guys (DF)

You don't trust Digital Foundry? I'd love to hear why

In reply to

koenshaku

Commented on 2015-05-17 05:51:12

Posted by droezelke

In fact people would be wrong that the game on PC would have looked as the reveal trailer. CDPR said it would look BETTER on PC than that. That wasn't said after the reveal, but after actual gameplay demo's that looked nowhere near the reveal trailer. CDPR has done the same thing as Ubisoft with WatchDogs. They utterly lied.
I know that the downgrade has been receiving criticism by gamers, but not even near the controversy when Ubisoft did the same thing.
Also, it is not mentioned in any review to date. I guess CDPR's reputation trumps the truth. In my opinion they are now in the same boat as Ubisoft. I will not trust their claims and reveal trailers anymore.

That being said: I will still enjoy the game on wednesday on PC (assuming that it will work on PC and performance is good). Downgrades are no shame for a company, as long as they admit that they did it. CDPR says they didn't. That is what makes them not trust worthy.

You are right in UBI's case I will never buy a pc game from them. Well I did buy last light on sale, but that is my intention. CDPR pulling the same, but making an amazing looking game regardless has stopped me from buying day one as I did with the Witcher 2. I may wait for a sale before buying it also it disappoints me to see this sort of thing from them.

In reply to

[quote=droezelke]

In fact people would be wrong that the game on PC would have looked as the reveal trailer. CDPR said it would look BETTER on PC than that. That wasn't said after the reveal, but after actual gameplay demo's that looked nowhere near the reveal trailer. CDPR has done the same thing as Ubisoft with WatchDogs. They utterly lied. 
I know that the downgrade has been receiving criticism by gamers, but not even near the controversy when Ubisoft did the same thing. 
Also, it is not mentioned in any review to date. I guess CDPR's reputation trumps the truth. In my opinion they are now in the same boat as Ubisoft. I will not trust their claims and reveal trailers anymore.

That being said: I will still enjoy the game on wednesday on PC (assuming that it will work on PC and performance is good). Downgrades are no shame for a company, as long as they admit that they did it. CDPR says they didn't. That is what makes them not trust worthy.[/quote]

You are right in UBI's case I will never buy a pc game from them. Well I did buy last light on sale, but that is my intention. CDPR pulling the same, but making an amazing looking game regardless has stopped me from buying day one as I did with the Witcher 2. I may wait for a sale before buying it also it disappoints me to see this sort of thing from them.

kraenk

Commented on 2015-05-17 11:49:07

Posted by koenshaku

Downgrades are no shame for a company, as long as they admit that they did it. CDPR says they didn't. That is what makes them not trust worthy.

"We just did not have the manpower, budget or the console power to produce the vision we intended before the consoles were released to create a more visually stunning game of higher fidelity like 2013 assets. The PCs themselves had more than enough power to achieve this vision, almost certainly. But working on the game across 3 platforms did not make it feasible to keep features included that could potentially break the game as we kept building around it. All the 2013 trailers were actually in-game footage (not prerendered or vertical slices) but essentially just not an entirely finished world running on a high-end PC at the time."

In reply to

This message and account have been deleted at the user's request

synce

Commented on 2015-05-17 16:05:17

It's not a good sign when the only thing people ever discuss about your game is the graphics.

In reply to

akimikage

Commented on 2015-05-17 16:28:55 In reply to synce

Posted by synce

It's not a good sign when the only thing people ever discuss about your game is the graphics.

Not really. It's how CDPR lied and continue to lie :)

In reply to

catfish

Commented on 2015-05-17 17:44:28 In reply to kraenk

Posted by kraenk

"We just did not have the manpower, budget or the console power to produce the vision we intended before the consoles were released to create a more visually stunning game of higher fidelity like 2013 assets. The PCs themselves had more than enough power to achieve this vision, almost certainly. But working on the game across 3 platforms did not make it feasible to keep features included that could potentially break the game as we kept building around it. All the 2013 trailers were actually in-game footage (not prerendered or vertical slices) but essentially just not an entirely finished world running on a high-end PC at the time."

I kind of doubt anyone at CDPR said that...I doubt it is entirely correct as well.

In reply to

This message and account have been deleted at the user's request

The Witcher 3: PS4 vs XB1 video

PS4/XB1 Comparison (v 1.01)

All comments (38)

TopSpin 2K25

Stellar Blade

Senua's Saga: Hellblade II

Kingdom Come: Deliverance II announced

Our PC video of Between Horizons

Our PC Video of Horizon Forbidden West in 4K