GSY REVIEW | X360, PS3, PC, PS4, Xbox One Tuesday, September 30, 2014 | 11:15 AM

We reviewed Sherlock Holmes C&P

We reviewed Sherlock Holmes C&P

Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments is now available on PC and consoles and here are a bunch of videos of the PC and PS4 versions. Overall, this new episode is a pleasant adventure game, but if you like a challenge, you might be a bit disappointed here. Frogwares decided to guide the player a lot in this new installment in the series, which means you'll often be told what to do. That being said, the game has some pretty interesting ideas, like the possibility to decide who the culprit must be depending on one's interpretation of the clues. As usual, if you want more details and the full review, head over to the French side.


Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments sometimes suffer a bit from its rigid structure, not unlike an episode of CSI or Columbo, but with six cases to solve it still manages to be pretty engaging. Technically imperfect (at least until a patch), Frogwares latest might also prove a bit easy for those accustomed to the genre. While the move to create something that appeals to a new audience is commendable and understandable from a business point of view, perhaps a more customizable experience would have resulted in something enjoyable for seasoned players and newcomers alike. Still, despite this issue, the latest journey into the world of Sherlock Holmes is once again a nice adventure game that will undoubtedly appeal to fans of the “so British” novels of Conan Doyle. We only hope that Frogwares can learn from their attempts to simplify the game and deliver something a bit more balanced next time.

On the plus side

+ 6 cases offer plenty of variety
+ Beautifully modeled faces
+ Welcoming for newcomers
+ Varied enigmas
+ Haunting atmosphere
+ Possible to make ones own conclusions
+ Reasonably lengthy (+/- 15h)
+ The episodic structure might allow for DLC?

On the down side

- The episodic nature isn’t quite as immersive
- Technical issues
- A bit too easy/accessible
- Overly guided, lack of freedom
- The disguises
- The scenario feels a bit too static

PS4 - Gameplay #1
PS4 - Gameplay #2
PS4 - Gameplay #3
PS4 - Gameplay #4
PC - Interrogations
PC - Investigations
PC - Puzzles
PC - Environments

All comments

Commented on 2014-09-30 12:51:01
Hmmm. I don't like if a game tells me exactly what i must do, but a bit more easy is not a bad thing i guess. I have not played many of the Sherlock games, but there definitely should have been a way to customise it yeah.

So how does it work? They flat out tell you what to do if you take too long or something?
Commented on 2014-10-13 08:04:56
It's boring :(

About the game

What's up?
  • b0vril
    b0vril @asdfg: omg haha! (15 minutes ago)
  • asdfg
    asdfg Remember to keep your distance on the virtual battlefield soldiers [url] (33 minutes ago)
  • asdfg
    asdfg @GriftGFX: I get it now, thx for explaining. :) (34 minutes ago)
  • GriftGFX
    GriftGFX It's not your W:L ratio.. which is what I think you really want. That's what I really want anyway. (1 Hour ago)
  • GriftGFX
    GriftGFX What I'm saying is: It should subtract ties from your games played before giving you that stat. (1 Hour ago)
  • GriftGFX
    GriftGFX That one sentence makes little sense but hopefully you get what I was trying to say lol (1 Hour ago)
  • GriftGFX
    GriftGFX because like 10% of my games are ties.. makes it seem like you have 10% more losses than you do :D (1 Hour ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood GSY is getting some nice content at 3 pm CEST with our July podcast and some videos of the Deus Ex Mankind Divided preview build. :) (> 3 Months ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood For once we'll be live at 4:30 pm CEST. Blim should not even be tired! (> 3 Months ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood More Quantum Break coverage coming in a few hours, 9:00 a.m CEST. (> 3 Months ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood We'll have a full review up for Firewatch at 7 pm CET. Videos will only be tomorrow though. (> 3 Months ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood Tonight's livestream will be at 9:15 GMT+1, not GMT+2 as first stated. (> 3 Months ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood New GSY Live dedicated this time to Just Cause 3 on Tuesday 9:30 GMT+2 (> 3 Months ago)
  • Driftwood
    Driftwood Join us tomorrow at 10 pm GMT+2 for a new livestream. We'll be playing Rise of the Tomb Raider. (> 3 Months ago)
Top stories