Game of Thrones Season 7: Winter Came (and so did I) ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

KORNdog
KORNdog
Since 6208 Days
Posted by Tinks
I think the reduction is why every battle happens instantly regardless of where it is. It's feeling kinda rushed IMO
had this discussion this morning with a workmate. as much as i like this quicker pace and actually seeing things happen for a change, it does feel very rushed when you put it next to all the other episodes in the series. it's like giving themselves a cut off point for the show has made them realise they actually have a lot to squeeze in in less episodes.
In reply to
Tiz
Tiz
Since 6469 Days
Posted by Sdarts
Another thing that was masterful was the fact that when Daenerys went with John into the dragonglass cave, Tyrion wasn't there, I remember thinking how seemingly insignificant, but important it was to let their relationship grow a little bit by their personalities alone, without needing to have Tyrion there. Was a very considerate restraint, that I definitely appreciated.
This was actually one of the worse parts for me in the episode. Not so much the interaction but the fact that "digging" for dragonglass apparently only means digging your heels into 3 inches of sand to get to these engravings left by the the Children thousands of years ago. It didn't seem like an excavation site, but rather a room with a long hallway where someone may or may not have forgotten the keys to.

I get things need to move forward and payoffs need to happen now, but some of the little exposition that is left is getting a little sloppy.

I'm still not entirely sure why Jon won't bend the knee. I mean, I don't want him to, but this could be part of that foolishness that Sansa was talking about where all the Stark men make dumb decisions. Jon has seen the Night King and keeps talking about how there'd be nothing to save if they don't band together. So if he doesn't bend the knee and Dany turns him down completely, he has to travel back North and die with his men in pieces but his honour intact or some bullshit.

This season so far is entertaining for sure and Episode 4 was one of the better spectacle episodes but as far as plot is concerned, we're losing that in favour of getting to the end in the most blockbuster way possible.

Love, Dickon.
In reply to

There are two rules to success:
___________________________________

1. Never tell all you know.

Tinks
Tinks
Since 6733 Days
^To both of you, I agree!
The slower pace is what made a lot of these huge moments so much more satisfying. If they went at their usual pace they could have easily added one maybe two more seasons.
I'll be curious to find out what the sudden rush is really. Maybe HBO is striking out elsewhere so they need those spin offs ASAP

I didn't have a huge problem with the children drawings in the cave really. I got the impression it was tucked away on the island where they wouldn't easily be found. Jon even said they hadn't really started digging yet. It's another traveling situation they likely skipped.
I'm really curious how shoehorned they'll be for the finale of the show though. Like is this conclusion gonna feel like cheap shit because they wanna tie it all up so quickly?

Also Bran has grown to be the worst part of the show - discuss
In reply to
Sdarts
Sdarts
Since 3948 Days
Posted by Tiz
This was actually one of the worse parts for me in the episode. Not so much the interaction but the fact that "digging" for dragonglass apparently only means digging your heels into 3 inches of sand to get to these engravings left by the the Children thousands of years ago. It didn't seem like an excavation site, but rather a room with a long hallway where someone may or may not have forgotten the keys to.
Actually, if you remember John's words, they still haven't started mining for dragonglass yet, they wanted to show Daenerys how the cave looked before they started mining, and also wanted to show her the drawings by the Forest people. It may not have had much of an impact for you, but if you have read the books and specially the compendiums, the Forest people's war against the First Men is very, very interesting, and absolutely worth reading the summaries if you can't read the whole thing. Basically, like the show has already shown, the Forest people created the Night King to fight the First Men, which were killing them and winning the war. But that weapon turned against them and was so strong that the Forest people even found themselves allying with their worst enemy, the First Men, in order to win against - momentarily stop - the Night King and the White Walkers. I'm saying all this history stuff, because Daenerys got it wrong, due to her lessons being misinformation on this subject, since no one knows how the Night King and the White Walkers came to be except for Bran - and possibly Meera. And the fact that she assumed they were fighting each other, when they were actually fighting together against their "true enemy". My point is, that segment had a lot of things inside it that were subtle and probably flew by unnoticed by most people. So both in how it developed John and Daenerys relationship, it also delve into some of the lore of A Song of Ice and Fire.
I get things need to move forward and payoffs need to happen now, but some of the little exposition that is left is getting a little sloppy.
Like I mentioned above and in one of my previous comments, while it may look like something insignificant, it is important, while being subtle. It shows there's a lot of care put into it, even if just a minority of people will fully grasp the significancy of it. It's the start - the real one, anyways, since the meeting and the conversations afterwards were more like introductions - of John and Daenerys relationship, where they are starting to trust each other more and more. Like John said, they can't win against the Night King and the White Walkers without her and her dragons. They need to work together. Which you can see the relevance of in the fact that immediately afterwards, Daenerys ignored Tyrion's advice and asked John what she should do next. This certainly wouldn't have happened if they hadn't gone into the cave.
I'm still not entirely sure why Jon won't bend the knee. I mean, I don't want him to, but this could be part of that foolishness that Sansa was talking about where all the Stark men make dumb decisions. Jon has seen the Night King and keeps talking about how there'd be nothing to save if they don't band together. So if he doesn't bend the knee and Dany turns him down completely, he has to travel back North and die with his men in pieces but his honour intact or some bullshit.
Like John mentioned in The Queen's Justice, everyone in Westeros grew up hearing stories about the Mad King - Aerys II Targaryen, Daenerys father - and how no one wants to trust a Targaryen ever again. To us, through our perspective, we know Daenerys, but to John and all those that only briefly met her or never met her before, her family name still instills fear and hatred among most people. So from John's perspective, who grew up hearing about how his father, his uncles and everyone else both in the North and in most of the Seven Kingdoms fought the Daenerys family's tyranny and all the atrocities they commited, including kidnapping, raping and killing hist aunt - which is actually his mother, how in the hell do you suppose he should trust her and bend the knee so easily. The most accurate analogy I can think of - not completely accurate, but the closer - is if Hitler or Osama Bin Laden had a daughter that was asking you to trust her completely, to bend the knee, to swear an oath of loyalty forever and ever till the end of time. Would you do after just a few conversations?

So through John's perspective, which also has the people in the North's perception of what "Rulers in the South" always mean for people in The North, not to mention the fact that everyone was against John even meeting Daenerys in the first place, and the fact that when he allowed the Wildlings to pass through The Wall, people bertrayed and even killed him, bending the knee to a conqueror - no matter how you look at it, Daenerys is still a conqueror - from the "South" whoi is also a Targaryen, when not even 20 or so years ago - John is supposed to be in his late 18 to early 20s in the books - his family's worst enemy was the Targaryens, this is not an easy task.

Also of very important note, is the fact that in the books, Bending the knee is "mostly considered shameful and disgraceful, but there are exceptions". This would be one of those exceptions, though like I've pointed above, it's not an easy task, even if it's the right one. Though, to be honest, while it is the right thing to do, you can be sure as hell that when John returns to the North, if he has indeed sworn feuty to Daenerys, a lot of people will turn against him, mostly likely meaning betrayals and such, which after the whole Castle Black experiences, John is definitely aware of. This could also be exactly the opportunity that Littlefinger is waiting for to try and put Samsa in charge and destroy John. It's not a very simple act to do, specially when you take into consideration what Daenerys's family name means.
This season so far is entertaining for sure and Episode 4 was one of the better spectacle episodes but as far as plot is concerned, we're losing that in favour of getting to the end in the most blockbuster way possible.
This season has a lot of subtleties, and a lot of fan service to people who really know the Game of Thrones' universe and lore. This is why the meeting of "Fire and Ice" in The Queen's Justice was such a letdown to many hardcore fans, it had many unfulfilled expectations. Still, overall this is a great season, and aside from the battle of Casterly Rock, the other battles were great. I know a lot of people felt that the naval battle of Stormborn was rushed, but the producers wanted to give the viewers the exact feeling that the characters experienced, it was an unexpected - till a certain point - attack that caught everyone off-guard and showed how incredibly fast, furious and brutal the Greyjoys' naval fleet could be, attacking hard and fast, and leaving in a matter of minutes. Anyway, that's how I'm seeing these events. I may be wrong or right, but as long as you're enjoying the episodes overall, there's nothing to worry about yet - except for Bronn and Brienne, I really don't want them to die. Ever. But it's Game of Thrones, so... just preparing my little heart in advance. T_T

PS.
Love, Dickon.
I loved that bit as well. Bronn always delivers. :D
In reply to
Sdarts
Sdarts
Since 3948 Days
Posted by Tinks
Also Bran has grown to be the worst part of the show - discuss
Yeah, Bran has really turned into a kind of dick, hasn't he?!

I get why, like he said to Meera, the memories of Bran are just one of many he has now, and you can still see that he cares a lot for his sisters, even though he was a complete asshole to Meera. Other than that, I feel like we will need to see how he develops for the rest of the season before we can properly judge his actions - the same with Daenerys and Samsa, to name a few.
In reply to
Loakum
Loakum
Since 5883 Days
I gotta talk about how freakin BADASS Arya was in this episode! She was walking around Winterfell like the boss she is. Even her sister Sansa was scared of her. I know Sansa wanted to ask Arya, if her name was on her list. Arya looked like she also wanted to ghost Littlefinger the instant she seen him. lol
In reply to
Tinks
Tinks
Since 6733 Days
I don't think Sansa is scared she's on the list, so much as she's scared of what Arya has become. She thought it was a joke when Arya first mentioned it but is realizing how truthful her list really is

I don't think he's a dick, I just think he's hard to care about
In reply to
Loakum
Loakum
Since 5883 Days
I see a lot of folks don't particularly like Bran this season, for a variety of reasons. Me, I actually like this season's Bran best. Why? Bran is on a whole diffrent level of consiousness. For Marvel Comics fans, Bran is basically a "Watcher". He seen the beginning of all creation and seen how it will all end. Bran knows answers to questions you haven't even asked yet. Basically Bran is no longer human. So things like courtesy and manners are just quaint human traits. Him being socially awkward is just a by-product of being a God like being. I can relate.
In reply to
Loakum
Loakum
Since 5883 Days
Posted by Tinks
I don't think Sansa is scared she's on the list, so much as she's scared of what Arya has become. She thought it was a joke when Arya first mentioned it but is realizing how truthful her list really is

I don't think he's a dick, I just think he's hard to care about
Well Sansa has to come to terms.....her siblings has changed...a lot. lol
In reply to
Tiz
Tiz
Since 6469 Days
Posted by Sdarts
It may not have had much of an impact for you, but if you have read the books and specially the compendiums, the Forest people's war against the First Men is very, very interesting, and absolutely worth reading the summaries if you can't read the whole thing. Basically, like the show has already shown, the Forest people created the Night King to fight the First Men, which were killing them and winning the war. But that weapon turned against them and was so strong that the Forest people even found themselves allying with their worst enemy, the First Men, in order to win against - momentarily stop - the Night King and the White Walkers.
I get all of that. My gripe isn't with the level of interest in the subject but more the drawings being so close to the entrance which were done by the Children thousands of years ago.

As an example, here in London you'd have to dig for a long time and pretty deep to get to the roads that were scorched by the Great Fire and that was only in 1666; even the dragonglass in the North that Grenn and Ed found back in season 2, they were digging at least 2 episodes.

I don't take issue with the material at all, but the way it is being handled is sloppy due to time and as Tinks said above, if this is the case, what stopped them from making at least one more season and keeping the number of episodes at 10?
Like John mentioned in The Queen's Justice, everyone in Westeros grew up hearing stories about the Mad King - Aerys II Targaryen, Daenerys father - and how no one wants to trust a Targaryen ever again. To us, through our perspective, we know Daenerys, but to John and all those that only briefly met her or never met her before, her family name still instills fear and hatred among most people. So from John's perspective, who grew up hearing about how his father, his uncles and everyone else both in the North and in most of the Seven Kingdoms fought the Daenerys family's tyranny and all the atrocities they commited, including kidnapping, raping and killing hist aunt - which is actually his mother, how in the hell do you suppose he should trust her and bend the knee so easily. The most accurate analogy I can think of - not completely accurate, but the closer - is if Hitler or Osama Bin Laden had a daughter that was asking you to trust her completely, to bend the knee, to swear an oath of loyalty forever and ever till the end of time. Would you do after just a few conversations?
I'd say to her: "I tell ya what. You, me, that badass plane of yours, circle around and scout the North for a bit and you can witness this indiscriminate WMD wreaking wanton destruction throughout the land, and if you're still convinced that my genuflecting before you is more important than stopping this? Then you're just as bad as your Father."

If I had the time of course.
This season has a lot of subtleties, and a lot of fan service to people who really know the Game of Thrones' universe and lore. This is why the meeting of "Fire and Ice" in The Queen's Justice was such a letdown to many hardcore fans, it had many unfulfilled expectations. Still, overall this is a great season, and aside from the battle of Casterly Rock, the other battles were great. I know a lot of people felt that the naval battle of Stormborn was rushed, but the producers wanted to give the viewers the exact feeling that the characters experienced, it was an unexpected - till a certain point - attack that caught everyone off-guard and showed how incredibly fast, furious and brutal the Greyjoys' naval fleet could be, attacking hard and fast, and leaving in a matter of minutes.
I think it's because they've got 7 episodes to pull off a bunch of payoffs, there's always subtleties in everything. You don't need to be a book reader to understand that Arya's: "That's not you." To Nymeria was a direct reference to when she said "That's not me." to Ned in Season 1.

I'm also dead certain that the reason they moved to a shorter season and releasing later in the year was because they wanted every episode to be intense, I mean, they are but the exposition has paid the price turning into bullet points rather than well-crafted paragraphs.
In reply to

There are two rules to success:
___________________________________

1. Never tell all you know.

rayy
rayy
Since 6778 Days
In reply to

Steam: Electro

Tinks
Tinks
Since 6733 Days
Meanwhile
In reply to
rayy
rayy
Since 6778 Days
In reply to

Steam: Electro

Loakum
Loakum
Since 5883 Days
Posted by rayy
lol, I like this. *goes to site*
In reply to
Loakum
Loakum
Since 5883 Days
Posted by Loakum
best so far. ^_Q (but I have a feeling episode 4 will be legendary)
Let it be known that I'm a prophet. Easily top 3 all time episodes of GoT. It's up there with "Battle of the Bastards" and "Hardhome".
In reply to
Loakum
Loakum
Since 5883 Days
I have to admit, I believe "The Spoils of War" is better than "The Battle of the Bastards", making it my new number #1 episode of the entire series of Game of Thrones. There, I said it.
In reply to
Tinks
Tinks
Since 6733 Days
Because they have to basically put a battle into every episode now to try and close this thing out, you may find each episode being your next favorite. There are so few battles in earlier seasons that it may be why you're feeling this way

I think for me Red Wedding will always be the most legendary. Even if I read about it already in the books.
It's what really got the show talked about early on
In reply to
Loakum
Loakum
Since 5883 Days
Posted by Tinks
Because they have to basically put a battle into every episode now to try and close this thing out, you may find each episode being your next favorite. There are so few battles in earlier seasons that it may be why you're feeling this way

I think for me Red Wedding will always be the most legendary. Even if I read about it already in the books.
It's what really got the show talked about early on
Nah, it was just the superior episode.
In reply to
rayy
rayy
Since 6778 Days
Ser Davos telling Gendry that he though he was still rowing. lol

Gendry using a hammer like Roberth is a nice touch to

And that team is gonna wreck shit.
In reply to

Steam: Electro

Tinks
Tinks
Since 6733 Days
Yeah that team up is possibly the coolest fuckin ever.

Like I LOVED the Hound+Arya combo, and I never thought they'd top that.
But you can't beat Gendry with the hammer, fire sword wielding Beric, the Hound, AND Jon
FUCK ME m8s
In reply to
Tinks
Tinks
Since 6733 Days
In reply to
Tiz
Tiz
Since 6469 Days
Even though this season is moving like a bullet train, I actually preferred this weeks episode to last weeks.

Not as if it is saying much though, this season is a season of payoffs and it is damn good for it, there really is no time to move slowly. Two more weeks, two more episodes and it is all over.

I really do wonder how it is all going to end? Imagine the army of the dead just rolls over the south?

Two wild guesses as to what is going to happen:

Cersei is about to get weirdly, poetically stabbed in her belly with child by Arya wearing Jamie's face (by about I mean season 8).

Bran is going to get to do some dragon warging, fuck it why not.
In reply to

There are two rules to success:
___________________________________

1. Never tell all you know.

Loakum
Loakum
Since 5883 Days
I feel Littlefinger is way over his head, now that the Starks has turned into the X-Men. I think Arya is allowing Littlefinger to think he fooled her. And when Jon Snow (Starkgaryan) told Daenerys, "I'm a King! I'll go when I want to go!" I was pumping my fist in the air! Jon has sooooo earned my respect this season. Last but not least the two mega TRUTH BOMBS told by Gilly and Queen Cercei was a perfect addition to a perfect episode! Season 7 is their best season ever (so far).
In reply to
Tinks
Tinks
Since 6733 Days
I think Cersei is gonna get turned into the Night QUEEN personally.

But yeah this weeks episode KIND of slowed down. Although Dany tele'd home and Jon made it beyond the wall in record time so I take it back


Was Sam about to reveal Jon's parents? Is that what Littlefinger found out too? Arya needs to kill that bitch
In reply to
Loakum
Loakum
Since 5883 Days
Posted by Tinks
I think Cersei is gonna get turned into the Night QUEEN personally.

But yeah this weeks episode KIND of slowed down. Although Dany tele'd home and Jon made it beyond the wall in record time so I take it back


Was Sam about to reveal Jon's parents? Is that what Littlefinger found out too? Arya needs to kill that bitch
It's pretty obvious Littlefinger found that note Cercei forced Sansa to write way back in season 1. He wants Arya to belive Sansa betrayed their family. It's a shame my PC is down, because I would be posting a ton of gifs from this episode.
In reply to
You have to be logged in to post in this forum!
Patreon

$135 of $400 per month

What's up?
  • Loakum

    Loakum *takes a sip of grape juice* The Great Awakening is happening…. (11 Weeks ago)

  • gigantor21

    gigantor21 We getting any Tekken 8 demo footage? (> 3 Months ago)

  • dc_coder_84

    dc_coder_84 Playing Half-Life 1 with ray tracing mod on Linux, yay ;) (> 3 Months ago)

  • nostradamus

    nostradamus MS-Bethesda-ABK does have some ring to it. My oh my, (> 3 Months ago)

  • Loakum

    Loakum Sony’s PlayStation Showcase was weaksauce….except for 5 great upcoming games. (> 3 Months ago)

  • Loakum

    Loakum *takes a sip of grape juice* Ah…such a good vintage. (> 3 Months ago)

  • nostradamus

    nostradamus @dc_coder_84: [url] (> 3 Months ago)

  • Driftwood

    Driftwood Download is now functional again on Gamersyde. Sorry for the past 53 days or so when it wasn't. (> 3 Months ago)

  • Driftwood

    Driftwood Another (French) livestream today at 2:30 CEST but you're welcome to drop by and speak English. I will gladly answer in English when I get a chance to catch a breath. :) (> 3 Months ago)

  • Driftwood

    Driftwood GSY is getting some nice content at 3 pm CEST with our July podcast and some videos of the Deus Ex Mankind Divided preview build. :) (> 3 Months ago)

  • Driftwood

    Driftwood For once we'll be live at 4:30 pm CEST. Blim should not even be tired! (> 3 Months ago)

  • Driftwood

    Driftwood More Quantum Break coverage coming in a few hours, 9:00 a.m CEST. (> 3 Months ago)

  • Driftwood

    Driftwood We'll have a full review up for Firewatch at 7 pm CET. Videos will only be tomorrow though. (> 3 Months ago)

  • Driftwood

    Driftwood Tonight's livestream will be at 9:15 GMT+1, not GMT+2 as first stated. (> 3 Months ago)

Also on Gamersyde

Our PS5 video of Tales of Kenzera: ZAU

  • Thursday, April 25, 2024
  • Driftwood

Our PC videos of Ereban: Shadow Legacy

  • Saturday, April 20, 2024
  • Driftwood